Cloud-based payroll software is payroll that runs in your browser and, on full-service plans, files your payroll taxes. Every provider I checked is web-based. So “cloud” decides nothing. What decides is which city, county and school-district taxes each one files. I checked 20 providers against the local taxes of 16 places, and the answer changed with the ZIP code.
- What is cloud-based payroll software?
- What does “full-service” payroll actually file?
- Which places tax paychecks, and who collects the tax?
- We checked 20 payroll providers in 16 local tax places
- Why do payroll providers skip some local taxes?
- Best cloud-based payroll software, by situation
- Your people work in Pennsylvania or Ohio: Patriot Full Service
- One state and no local taxes: Square Payroll or Gusto
- Remote hires in several states: Square or OnPay
- You already run payroll in QuickBooks
- You want to file the taxes yourself
- You only pay contractors: Square
- Payroll inside your bank or accounting software
- Restaurants and hourly teams: Toast, 7shifts or Homebase
- HR and payroll in one system
- What does a second state cost?
- Who presses “file”: automatic filing or doing it yourself?
- Is desktop or free payroll software still worth it?
- What if an employee lives in one place and works in another?
- How to find your own local taxes in 10 minutes
- What to ask a payroll provider before you sign
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a cloud-based payroll system?
- Does Gusto file local taxes in every city?
- Can I just use QuickBooks for payroll?
- Which payroll software handles Pennsylvania local taxes?
- Is ADP Workforce Now cloud-based?
- Can ChatGPT do payroll for a small business?
- How much does cloud payroll software cost per month?
- Is cloud payroll software safe for employee data?
- Do I register in a new state for one remote employee?
- My Take
Gusto’s own help center says it files “most local taxes.” It adds that “a few local taxes are exceptions” and sends you into your account to find out which. QuickBooks’ entry payroll plan doesn’t file local taxes at all. Patriot publishes a table, place by place, and names the one city on my list it skips. None of the 11 ranking pages I read on October 24, 2026 named a single city tax.
What is cloud-based payroll software?
Cloud-based payroll software is a web service that calculates pay and, on full-service plans, files payroll taxes for you. It turns hours and salaries into paychecks, withholds taxes and sends the money and the returns to the IRS, the state and local agencies. The provider keeps the tax tables current. You don’t install updates.
That definition used to set it apart from desktop programs, where the software sat on your PC and you filed the forms yourself. In 2026 it sets nothing apart. All 20 providers in my census run in a browser or an app. So does the payroll button inside your bank or accounting software. That button is often another payroll company’s engine with a new logo on top.
Three neighbors get mixed up with it. A payroll service adds people who run payroll for you. A PEO files payroll taxes under its own tax ID as your co-employer. Desktop payroll, which still exists, calculates on your computer and leaves the filing to you. Below, I compare what each one files, where, and who presses the button.
“Cloud” tells you where the software runs. It doesn’t tell you which of your taxes it files.
What does “full-service” payroll actually file?
Full-service payroll files the federal and state layers almost everywhere. A payroll provider can file in every state and still skip a city, county or school-district tax. The local layer is where it stops being a promise and becomes a list. A provider files for you as your reporting agent, after you sign Form 8655, the IRS authorization that lets it act for you.
Here is what each layer means for a small employer:
- Federal: income tax withholding, Social Security and Medicare, federal unemployment tax, quarterly Form 941, annual Form 940, and W-2s to the Social Security Administration.
- State: income tax withholding, state unemployment insurance, and paid family or disability leave programs in the states that run them.
- Local: city wage taxes, county income taxes, school-district taxes, transit taxes and flat occupational taxes, each with its own collector, forms and deadlines.
The full-service plans I checked all promise the first two layers. That’s fair. Filing federal and state returns in all 50 states is the hard, standardized part. The local layer is not standardized. Gusto puts it plainly: it files “most local taxes set up in your account. These can be city, county, school district, or transit taxes. A few local taxes are exceptions.”
Most providers in my census use some version of the phrase “federal, state and local” on their marketing pages. Read on its own, that phrase sounds complete. Read next to the help center, it usually means “local where we support it.”
Which places tax paychecks, and who collects the tax?
Local payroll taxes exist in a minority of places. They aren’t rare. The Tax Foundation counts 5,055 local income tax jurisdictions, “encompassing counties, cities, school districts, and special taxing districts,” in 16 states. Not every one is a payroll tax you withhold. Enough are that one remote hire can add one.
The detail that trips up payroll software is the collector. In Pennsylvania, local earned income tax goes to a county collector under Act 32, not to the city. Elsewhere, too, you often file with an agency other than the city:
- Pennsylvania’s earned income tax (EIT) is the local tax on wages. Its local services tax (LST) is owed where people work. Both go to county tax collection districts set up under Act 32 of 2008, which appoint collectors such as Keystone Collections Group, Berkheimer and Jordan Tax Service. Philadelphia runs its own wage tax.
- Ohio cities collect income tax through the Regional Income Tax Agency (RITA), through the Central Collection Agency (CCA) or on their own, as Columbus does. Ohio’s school-district income tax goes to the state, on forms SD-101 and SD-141.
- Detroit’s city income tax goes to the state: the Michigan Department of Treasury says it “began processing returns and associated payments in 2017 on behalf of the City of Detroit.”
- Portland’s Revenue Division collects both Metro’s supportive housing services tax and Multnomah County’s preschool for all tax. The city says it “administers these taxes on behalf of Metro and Multnomah County.”
- Kansas City has required electronic filing of its RD-110 earnings tax return since January 1, 2021, through its Quick Tax site or “the Bulk Filing Program through a third-party payroll provider.”
That is why providers write their lists by collector, not by city. Square’s Ohio page doesn’t promise “Ohio cities.” It names RITA, CCA and the City of Columbus, and says that for any other municipality it “will calculate your liability but will not file/pay on your behalf.”

Pennsylvania has one shortcut. The state’s Department of Community and Economic Development lets an employer with sites in several collection districts pick one collector for all earned income tax. The condition: it files “electronically and on a monthly basis, rather than quarterly.” The option “does not apply to the Local Services Tax,” so the LST can still go to several collectors.
To test the providers, I picked 16 places that cover the main kinds of local payroll tax. Here they are: Philadelphia, Pittsburgh under Act 32, Columbus, a city that files through RITA, Ohio’s school-district tax, Detroit, Kansas City, St. Louis, Louisville Metro, Denver’s occupational privilege tax, Portland Metro and Multnomah County, Oregon’s statewide transit tax with TriMet, Indiana’s county tax, Birmingham, Alabama, New York City and Newark, New Jersey. Two of them, Portland and Oregon’s transit row, carry two taxes each.
We checked 20 payroll providers in 16 local tax places
When I asked Google for the best payroll software on October 24, 2026, its AI Overview said Gusto offers “automated federal, state, and local tax filings.” Gusto’s own help center says “most.” That gap is why I ran a census of cloud-based payroll software. On October 23 and 24, 2026, I read the public help, support and pricing pages of 20 providers. I recorded what each one says it files, place by place.
The ranking pages repeat the general version. Expert Market’s list of the five best cloud-based payroll solutions describes picks with lines like “automated federal, state and local tax filing.” Forbes, CNBC, HiBob and OnPay’s own ranking use the same three words. None of them says which locals.
The 20 are Gusto, RUN Powered by ADP, Roll by ADP, Paychex Flex, QuickBooks Workforce, OnPay, Patriot, Square Payroll, Rippling, Paylocity, Paycor, Justworks, Deel, Wave, Homebase, SurePayroll, Toast, Zoho Payroll, BambooHR and Payroll4Free. Brands that run on these or other engines, such as 7shifts (Check) and FreshBooks (Gusto), came up along the way. Everything here is about US payroll for businesses. Household employers who file Schedule H are a separate market; Wave, for one, says its payroll “does not support employers required to deposit taxes against and file IRS Schedule H.”
I didn’t sign up for any of them or run a live payroll. I read what each company publishes to anyone who asks before buying. That limits what I can say. When a provider’s page doesn’t mention a city, it means the provider didn’t tell me, not that it can’t file there. Gusto, for example, keeps its list of exceptions inside your account.
Of 20 payroll providers I checked, six publish a list that names the local taxes they file or skip. Three list what they file: Patriot and Square place by place, Wave state by state. Three list what they don’t: Homebase, Zoho Payroll and Toast. Gusto tells you to look it up in your account. QuickBooks draws the line by plan. Of the other 12, seven describe local taxes in one general sentence, four didn’t mention them on the pages I read, and Payroll4Free’s free tier only calculates.
The lists don’t agree. The differences land on real places. Patriot’s Full Service table marks 15 of my 16 places as filed, including “all Pennsylvania local income taxes” and “all Indiana counties with local withholding.” It names the exception in a footnote: “Patriot does not calculate or file Newark local payroll taxes.” Square names 11 of the 16 places by collector, city or form. It also names Oregon’s statewide transit tax, half of the Oregon row. Its state pages say nothing about Louisville, Birmingham, Portland’s two taxes, TriMet or Newark.
QuickBooks is the sharpest split. On QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, the entry plan, its help article says “You’ll need to pay and file your local taxes manually outside of QuickBooks.” On Premium and Elite, “Your local tax payments and forms will be handled automatically,” with no list of places. And in May 2026 QuickBooks stopped filing Birmingham’s tax: the city “will no longer accept paper coupons or checks as of June 1st,” QuickBooks wrote, and “has chosen not to implement an electronic bulk payment and filing program.” Patriot’s table still marks Birmingham as filed. I couldn’t confirm whether Patriot files through the city’s own portal or hasn’t updated the table, so a Birmingham employer should ask Patriot in writing.
Two lists turned out almost identical. Homebase and Zoho Payroll each publish the local taxes they don’t support. Each names 74 different taxes, and 73 of them match, down to Kentucky tax-increment districts and Ohio joint economic development districts. Both lists include Newark’s employer expense tax. Zoho says it offers payroll “through our partnership with Check,” and Check lists Homebase among its customer stories, so the shared list likely comes from the engine underneath.
How to read a “not stated” cell
A “not stated” cell means the provider’s public pages didn’t name the place when I read them on October 23 and 24, 2026. It isn’t a verdict. Before you sign, send the provider your work and home addresses and ask in writing which local taxes it will file, pay and put on your W-2s.
Wave shows how fast these pages change. Its tax-service terms, effective August 16, 2021, are still posted. They cover a short list of states, and the filing authorization “specifically excludes payroll tax returns for city, county and school district payroll taxes.” Its help center, updated October 12, 2026, says “Wave offers tax payments and filings in all 50 US states” and that “only the taxes listed below will be paid and filed by Wave.” I trust the newer page. Wave moved its payroll to Check’s engine in between. But both are live. A buyer who finds the old one first gets the wrong answer.
Why do payroll providers skip some local taxes?
Because each local tax is a separate connection to build and keep alive, and some agencies make that hard. The exceptions I found fall into five groups.

- Some agencies give payroll companies no electronic route. Birmingham is the live example: QuickBooks stopped filing there because the city ended paper filing and, in QuickBooks’ words, “has chosen not to implement an electronic bulk payment and filing program.”
- Some agencies approve software vendors first. Ohio’s RITA, in the version of its bulk-filing page archived in June 2026, accepts bulk filings “using software from a RITA approved software vendor,” and payroll software companies “must submit the RITA eServices Software Application” to join. Kansas City runs its own bulk filing program for third-party payroll providers.
- Many exceptions are tiny special districts. The Homebase and Zoho lists are full of them: Kentucky tax-increment financing districts and Ohio joint economic development districts, each with its own rate and return.
- Some are taxes on the employer rather than the paycheck. Newark’s employer expense tax, Jersey City’s employer tax and Seattle’s payroll expense tax are on both the Homebase and Zoho lists.
- Some withholding is optional. In Ohio, Check’s documentation says, “Withholding an employee’s residence Ohio City Tax is considered a courtesy withholding,” and Toast lists Ohio courtesy withholding among the taxes it doesn’t process.
None of these is a reason to avoid a provider outright. They are where cloud-based payroll software most often hands the work back to you, so ask about them first.
When your tax lands on a skip list, the provider may still calculate it, as Square does in Ohio. You register with the collector, file its return and pay it yourself. For Pennsylvania collectors it doesn’t file with, Square says it will provide “a quarterly report containing detailed wage information.”
Best cloud-based payroll software, by situation
I ranked by one thing: does the provider file the taxes where your people work and live, and does it tell you so before you pay? Features and design come second. So the best payroll software for you depends on your addresses. The short version: Pennsylvania or Ohio, Patriot Full Service; one state with no local tax, Square or Gusto; several states, Square or OnPay. Prices are list prices from each provider’s pricing page in October 2026, before promotions.
Your people work in Pennsylvania or Ohio: Patriot Full Service
Patriot is the only provider I found that puts every state in one table. It files every Pennsylvania local income tax and every Ohio local tax. That includes city taxes through “RITA, CCA, or individual city forms,” school-district taxes and the joint economic development districts that Homebase and Zoho list as unsupported. Full Service costs $37 a month plus $5 per person. Its Basic plan at $17 plus $4 calculates but leaves the filing to you. An Ohio employer with one remote hire in Pennsylvania also pays Patriot’s $12 fee for the second state.
Square is the alternative if your collectors are on its list. Square files Ohio city taxes only through RITA, CCA and Columbus, and only calculates them elsewhere. In Pennsylvania it files with 15 earned income tax collectors and 10 local services tax collectors, plus Pittsburgh and Philadelphia. Check the split. Jordan Tax Service is on its earned income tax list but missing from the local services tax list.
One state and no local taxes: Square Payroll or Gusto
If every employee works in one state with no city or county tax, the local question disappears. Price takes over. Square Payroll costs $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. Gusto’s Simple plan costs $49 plus $6 and covers one state only: “Run basic payroll in one state.”
I’d pick Gusto if you want benefits and HR tools in the same place, and Square if you already take payments with Square. Both file automatically. Gusto is blunt about that: “We do not hold them or wait for your approval.” For the full Gusto bill, including the fees the plan card leaves out, see my breakdown of Gusto’s plans and fees.
In some states, Gusto’s “most” is less vague than it sounds. Its Ohio list names the school-district forms SD-101 and SD-141 and the municipal Form 11, so an Ohio employer can see more than the general sentence promises. The exceptions themselves still live inside the account.
Remote hires in several states: Square or OnPay
OnPay has one plan: $49 a month plus $6 per person. Its pricing page says you can “pay workers in as many states as you need” at no extra cost. A 10-person company that adds one remote hire in another state pays $6 more a month. On Gusto, the same hire moves you from Simple to Plus and nearly doubles the bill.
Square works the same way, with no state fee, and its bill stayed below OnPay’s in the same case. It also names more of the local taxes it files, so I’d start with Square and keep OnPay as the one-plan alternative. Patriot adds $12 for every state you add, so one extra state already put it above Square.
OnPay’s weak spot is the one most of the field shares. Its help center says it files “any other local payroll taxes required by your county, city, commonwealth, township, or any other government tax office,” without a list. If your new hire lives in a city with its own tax, ask OnPay to confirm that city by name.
You already run payroll in QuickBooks
Stay on QuickBooks only if you’re on Premium or Elite, or if you have no local taxes. QuickBooks Workforce is the product; Workforce Payroll, Premium and Elite are its plans. Workforce Payroll, the entry plan, leaves local taxes to you; only Premium and Elite file them automatically. QuickBooks lists Workforce Payroll at $50 a month plus $7 per employee, Premium at $88 plus $13 and Elite at $134 plus $17. The local taxes are the reason to pay for the jump.
The second QuickBooks change is about control. Since July 1, 2026, QuickBooks Workforce pays and files every tax you’ve set up, for every customer. Intuit’s notice says “the ability to turn off Automated Taxes will no longer be available.” Did you like approving each payment? That option is gone.
You want to file the taxes yourself
Pick a plan that only calculates. Patriot’s Basic payroll, at $17 a month plus $4 per person, runs payroll and gives you the reports, and you deposit and file. Payroll4Free calculates for free and sells its tax filing service as an option. Both leave every agency deadline, including the local ones, on your calendar.
QuickBooks is no longer an option for this. Neither is Gusto, which files on its own schedule once you’re set up. If you want the filing on your own computer, see the desktop section below.
You only pay contractors: Square
You don’t withhold payroll taxes from contractors, so the local question mostly drops away and the 1099 at year end matters more. Square’s contractor-only payroll costs $6 a month per person paid, with no base fee. Gusto’s pricing page listed no contractor-only plan when I read it on October 24, 2026; you can still pay contractors on any Gusto plan.
Whichever you pick, check that it files the 1099-NEC with the IRS and the state instead of only producing a PDF. Gusto’s help center says it files 1099s “for all contractors, even if they earned less than $600.”
Payroll inside your bank or accounting software
Find out whose engine it is. That company’s tax list is the one that applies. FreshBooks says its payroll “uses Gusto’s tax payment system to file and pay your state, and municipal payroll taxes.” Chase Payroll and Xero’s US payroll also run on Gusto. Wave says it “partners with Check to provide payroll and tax services in the US,” and ADP runs Clover’s payroll.

That doesn’t make the bank’s version worse. Chase Payroll, for one, charges less than Gusto for the same engine. It does mean the local taxes you get are the engine’s, and support for a local tax notice may pass between two companies.
Restaurants and hourly teams: Toast, 7shifts or Homebase
All three publish something you can check before signing. Toast keeps a page called “Taxes We Do Not Process,” which includes Multnomah County’s preschool for all tax and Ohio local courtesy withholding. 7shifts, which runs on Check, lists the local forms it files, such as Ohio’s school-district SD-101 and Oregon’s statewide transit return. Homebase lists 74 taxes and forms it doesn’t support.
For a restaurant in Portland, that Toast line matters. Both Portland taxes are personal income taxes that employers must withhold from people who earn $200,000 or more working there. Few line cooks will hit that. A general manager might. If you need both filed, Patriot’s table lists Metro’s supportive housing services tax and Multnomah County’s preschool tax.
HR and payroll in one system
Rippling, BambooHR and Gusto sell payroll inside a bigger HR software platform. Rippling says it files “with the correct federal, state, and local agencies,” and BambooHR says it takes care of “all federal, state, and local taxes for your US-based workers.” Neither Rippling’s nor BambooHR’s payroll page named a single place when I read them in October 2026. If you’re buying one as your HRIS, put the local tax question in the same email as the security questions. Read what Rippling’s price quote leaves out before you compare prices.
What does a second state cost?
With cloud-based payroll software, a second state can cost nothing extra, a flat add-on, a fee per state or a whole plan upgrade, depending on the provider. I priced one case: a company with 10 employees in its home state hires one remote employee in another state. The monthly bill before and after, at list prices from October 2026:
- OnPay and Square charge only for the extra person, with no state fee. OnPay’s pricing page says “Pay workers in as many states as you need,” and Square says that “for each state or tax jurisdiction in which you process payroll” it remits and files.
- Patriot’s Full Service adds a flat fee “for each additional state that we file in,” $12 a month, according to its pricing page as archived on September 29, 2026.
- Gusto moves you up a plan. Simple covers one state, and Plus, at $80 a month plus $12 per person, is the first plan with multi-state payroll. The new seat and the higher base fee arrive together.
Of the four I priced, Square came out cheapest after the hire, and Gusto’s jump to Plus was the biggest. SurePayroll uses the flat model: “First state included. Multi-state payroll for $9.99/month.” ADP, Paychex and Paylocity ask for a quote. Rippling’s and Paycor’s pricing pages showed no second-state price when I read them in October 2026, so I couldn’t price the case for them.
The software fee is the small part. The new state also means a withholding account, an unemployment insurance account and, in some places, a local registration. Some providers register you, sometimes for a fee: Gusto sells state tax registration as a separate service, which I priced in the Gusto fee breakdown. Others expect you to bring the account numbers. Deel’s help center, for one, lists the employer’s job in a new state as “Provide required state and local Tax IDs, or complete registrations”.
Who presses “file”: automatic filing or doing it yourself?
On most cloud payroll, the provider presses “file.” At Gusto and QuickBooks, you can’t stop it. Gusto sends payments and returns “automatically, based on the schedules in your account. We do not hold them or wait for your approval.” Since July 1, 2026, QuickBooks Workforce pays and files every set-up tax automatically, with no way to turn it off. Customers who signed up after November 15, 2025 had it from the start.

The QuickBooks change drew a 32-reply thread on Intuit’s community board. One of the sharpest replies came from an accountant. “What about those of us who LIKE doing payroll taxes for clients, and those clients WANT us to do their payroll tax returns? Is there NO way to opt out of this?” asked a user named SirMatthew. Another, dirtzero, wrote: “We are immediately exploring other payroll provider options because of this change.” A third, CJinx, named the catch: “I also have multi-state payroll which makes it more difficult to find options.”
If you run payroll for clients and want to keep filing, look for a plan that only calculates: Patriot Basic, or Payroll4Free’s free tier. If you want the provider to file, automatic is fine, but confirm two things in writing. Which taxes are “set up,” because QuickBooks pays and files only “all taxes that have been set up.” And what happens when a filing fails, because Gusto says that after three failed filings “you’ll need to file taxes outside of Gusto.”
Is desktop or free payroll software still worth it?
For a one-state business with a few salaried employees and no local taxes, yes. For anyone else, the cost moves from the software bill to your time.
When I read Intuit’s QuickBooks Desktop page on October 24, 2026, the Desktop product on sale was Enterprise; Desktop Pro and Premier appeared only as versions to migrate from. Smaller programs survive. Halfpricesoft still sells ezPaycheck for Windows and Mac, with e-filing for forms like the 941 sold separately. With any of them, you file.
Free cloud payroll works the same way. Payroll4Free calculates pay and taxes at no charge and “can also make all necessary deposits and filings on your behalf if you choose” for a monthly fee. Federal tax deposits are free through the Treasury’s EFTPS payment system, though you still file the returns; the state and local halves mean an account on every agency’s portal. I covered the full do-it-yourself route in my guide to running payroll yourself versus hiring a service.
What if an employee lives in one place and works in another?
Then the software has to know both addresses. Local taxes follow different rules.
Pennsylvania’s earned income tax looks at both. For an employee who lives in one Pennsylvania municipality and works in another, the state’s guidance says you withhold “the higher of the two EIT Rates.” The local services tax goes where the person works. Ohio splits it differently again: Check’s developer documentation notes that Ohio employers must withhold city tax where employees work, and that withholding for the city where they live “is considered a courtesy withholding.”
Remote work makes this ordinary. A hire who works from home can bring a new municipality and a new collector. When you add someone, enter both the home and work address in the payroll system, then check the next pay stub for a local line. If no local line appears where you expected one, ask before the quarter closes.
How to find your own local taxes in 10 minutes
Before you compare any cloud-based payroll software, list the local taxes you owe. It takes one address per employee and a few state lookups:
- Write down each employee’s work address and home address. Remote employees have the same address twice.
- Pennsylvania: look up each municipality’s PSD code and earned income tax rates on the Department of Community and Economic Development’s Act 32 pages. The code tells you the collector.
- Ohio: use the state’s municipality finder to see whether a city files through RITA, CCA or on its own. Then check the Ohio Department of Taxation’s school-district list for the home address.
- Indiana: the state’s Departmental Notice #1 lists the withholding rate for each of the 92 counties.
- Everywhere else: search the city name plus “earnings tax,” “occupational tax” or “payroll tax,” and the county name plus “transit tax.”
- Send the finished list to every provider you’re considering and ask which items it files and pays. The answer to that email is worth more than a feature comparison.
If the list comes back empty, stop worrying about the local layer. Pick on price and features. If it doesn’t, start with the provider that publishes an answer for every line on your list.
What to ask a payroll provider before you sign
Send these by email and keep the answers. A sales call is the wrong place for them.
- Here are our work and home addresses. Which local taxes will you file and pay for each employee?
- Do you publish a list of the local taxes you don’t file, and where?
- For a supported local tax, do you file and pay it, or only calculate it?
- Which plan do we need for employees in a second state, and what does each extra state cost?
- Will you register us with new state and local agencies, and is there a fee?
- Can we file a tax ourselves, or do you file everything automatically?
- Whose payroll engine is this, and who answers a notice from a local tax office?
- If we leave mid-year, what history can we take with us? (What to carry over is in my guide to switching HR software mid-year.)
One thing you don’t need to ask is who owes the tax. The IRS holds the employer responsible for federal payroll taxes even when a provider files them. I cover what providers promise when they get it wrong, and what their contracts say, in my piece on who pays when a payroll provider makes a mistake.
Field notes
- The census: 20 providers, 16 local tax places; help centers, support lists and pricing pages read October 23 and 24, 2026; no accounts opened, no live payroll run.
- Who publishes a list: 6 of 20 name places; Patriot and Square list what they file place by place, Wave state by state; Homebase, Zoho Payroll and Toast list what they don’t.
- Plan gates: QuickBooks Workforce Payroll files no local taxes; Premium and Elite do; Gusto needs Plus for a second state.
- Same engine, same gaps: Homebase and Zoho each name 74 unsupported taxes; 73 match.
- Who presses file: QuickBooks automatic for all customers since July 1, 2026; Gusto “do not hold them or wait for your approval”; Patriot Basic and Payroll4Free’s free tier leave filing to you.
- The ranking pages: 0 of 11 named a city, county or school-district tax.
- Sources: provider help centers and pricing pages; Pennsylvania DCED; Michigan Department of Treasury; City of Portland Revenue Division; Kansas City Revenue Division; RITA; Ohio Department of Taxation; Tax Foundation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a cloud-based payroll system?
It is payroll software you use in a browser or app instead of installing it. It calculates pay and withholding, pays employees, and on full-service plans pays and files payroll taxes for you. The provider updates the tax tables.
Does Gusto file local taxes in every city?
No, not every one. Gusto says it files “most local taxes set up in your account” and that “a few local taxes are exceptions.” It doesn’t publish the exceptions. Find them under Taxes & compliance, then Tax setup, or ask support.
Can I just use QuickBooks for payroll?
Yes, if you have no local taxes or you pay for Premium or Elite. On the entry plan, Workforce Payroll, you still file local taxes yourself. For every tax QuickBooks does file, automatic filing has been mandatory since July 1, 2026.
Which payroll software handles Pennsylvania local taxes?
Patriot Full Service says it “supports all Pennsylvania local income taxes.” Square names the collectors it files with: 15 for earned income tax and 10 for local services tax, plus Pittsburgh and Philadelphia. Most other providers publish no list.
Is ADP Workforce Now cloud-based?
Yes, in practice: Workforce Now is an online HR and payroll platform you sign in to, priced by quote. For small companies ADP sells RUN Powered by ADP, which says it “deducts and files federal, state and local payroll taxes,” without a public list of places.
Can ChatGPT do payroll for a small business?
No. A chatbot can explain a withholding rule or check a calculation, but it can’t pay employees, deposit taxes or file returns with the IRS or a city. Payroll software does that as your authorized agent. For the paperwork around it, see AI automation tools.
How much does cloud payroll software cost per month?
Published October 2026 list prices for plans that file your taxes started at $29 a month plus $5 per person at Zoho Payroll, billed yearly, and $29 plus $7 at SurePayroll. Square was $35 plus $6 and Patriot’s Full Service $37 plus $5. ADP and Paychex quote prices.
Is cloud payroll software safe for employee data?
It holds Social Security numbers and bank details, so the account login matters most. Require multi-factor sign-in and use passkeys where the provider offers them. Treat any email or call asking to change an employee’s direct deposit as a possible scam until you confirm it.
Do I register in a new state for one remote employee?
Usually yes. A remote employee who works from home in another state means a withholding account and an unemployment insurance account there, and sometimes a local one. Some payroll providers register you; others expect you to bring the account numbers.
My Take
If my staff lived in Pennsylvania or Ohio, I’d hand the payroll to Patriot Full Service. Of the 20 providers I checked, it was the only one that put in writing, before any sale, that it files every local income tax in both states. If I had a handful of people in one state with no city tax, I’d take Square or Gusto and stop worrying about the local layer. If I hired across states, I’d pick Square or OnPay. The second state barely changed the bill.
I wouldn’t sign with anyone who answers “which local taxes do you file?” with “federal, state and local.” That phrase is on most of the cloud-based payroll software marketing pages I read, and it told me less than one line from a help center. And if I were on QuickBooks Workforce Payroll with a city tax, I’d either move up to Premium or move out. Right now that tax is mine to file.








